EtG vs breathalyzer: which alcohol test should you use?

In short

Use a breathalyzer to learn whether someone has alcohol in their body right now, and an EtG urine test to learn whether they have been drinking over the past few days. Blackburn Monitoring in Los Angeles usually uses both on one visit, by appointment at 12326 Venice Blvd or with mobile testing across Los Angeles County. Call (888) 305-5422.

Key facts

  • A breathalyzer answers “right now.” It measures alcohol in the breath at the moment of the test, usually a window of hours.
  • EtG answers “recently.” It finds a marker of drinking in urine, often for one to three days and sometimes longer.
  • Most monitoring plans use both. Breath for the moment, EtG for the days between tests.
  • Neither test measures how drunk someone was over the whole period, and an EtG screen that will be acted on should be laboratory confirmed.

EtG vs breathalyzer: side by side

BreathalyzerEtG urine test
What it measuresAlcohol in the breath, which reflects alcohol in the blood nowEthyl glucuronide, a marker the body makes when it processes alcohol
How far back it looksHoursOften one to three days; up to 5 days at a 500 ng/mL cutoff, per Mayo Clinic Laboratories
Best question it answersIs this person under the influence right now?Has this person been drinking over the past few days?
Common usesSpot checks, workplace incidents, a check at each appointmentRandom alcohol monitoring, family agreements, aftercare, court referred testing
Main limitationMisses drinking that ended hours earlierSensitive to incidental exposure; cannot show how much or exactly when
ConfirmationRead at the visitPartner laboratory confirmation when a result will be acted on, usually 1 to 3 business days

Which alcohol test should you use?

  • Use a breathalyzer

    When the question is whether someone is impaired right now, such as before driving, at work after an incident, or at the start of a visit.

  • Use EtG

    When the question is whether someone has been drinking at all, such as on a family agreement, after treatment, or when a court referred plan requires abstinence.

  • Use both

    When alcohol is the main worry and testing is random. Breath covers the moment, EtG covers the days between tests, and a monitoring coordinator reads them together.

Lower EtG cutoffs catch more drinking over time. A study of treatment patients by Lowe and colleagues found the best performing cutoffs fell as the time since drinking grew, and that the common 500 ng/mL cutoff missed more drinking than lower ones. Our EtG window explainer shows the idea in a chart.

What can affect each result?

Breathalyzer

Alcohol in the mouth, such as from mouthwash, can raise a reading for a short time, so tell the collector if you used mouthwash or a breath spray. A zero reading only means no alcohol is in the breath now.

EtG

Because EtG is so sensitive, alcohol based hand sanitizer, mouthwash and similar products can produce low level results, as Mayo Clinic Laboratories notes. Use alcohol free products while on an EtG plan, tell us what you used, and see EtG and incidental alcohol. Positive EtG screens that will be acted on can be confirmed by a partner laboratory.

How alcohol testing works at Blackburn Monitoring

  1. Call us. Call (888) 305-5422 and say what you need the alcohol testing to show and who will see results.
  2. Set the plan. A coordinator chooses breath, EtG or both, and how often, case by case.
  3. Check in daily. On a random plan, a daily check-in tells you whether today is a test day.
  4. Test by appointment. At 12326 Venice Blvd in West Los Angeles, at an evening or weekend appointment, or at home or work with mobile testing across Los Angeles County, priced per test.
  5. Get results. Breath and EtG strip results are read at the visit; laboratory confirmation usually takes 1 to 3 business days.

Learn more about the breathalyzer test, the EtG alcohol test, alcohol monitoring for a family member, and how breath, EtG, PEth and remote devices compare in alcohol tests compared. If drinking is a concern for you, the NIAAA’s Rethinking Drinking is a good place to start.

Sources

This page is general information, not medical or legal advice. If someone is in danger, call 911. For a mental health or suicide crisis, call or text 988.

Common questions

Which is better for alcohol monitoring, EtG or a breathalyzer?

For monitoring over time, EtG usually tells you more, because it can show drinking over recent days while a breath test only shows alcohol in the body at that moment. Most plans use both: breath for right now and EtG to cover the gaps between tests.

Can a breathalyzer detect drinking from last night?

Usually not by the next afternoon. Breath alcohol falls as the body clears alcohol, often within hours of the last drink. An EtG urine test is the better choice for the night before.

How far back does an EtG test go?

Often one to three days, and longer after heavy drinking. Mayo Clinic Laboratories states EtG can be detected for up to 5 days at a 500 ng/mL cutoff. The real window depends on how much was consumed, when, and the cutoff used.

Can hand sanitizer or mouthwash cause a positive EtG?

Incidental exposure to alcohol based products can produce detectable EtG at low levels. Use alcohol free products while on an EtG plan and tell your coordinator about anything you used.

Does Blackburn Monitoring offer both tests at one visit?

Yes. At collection we use a breathalyzer plus an EtG strip on the urine cup, by appointment at 12326 Venice Blvd or with mobile testing across Los Angeles County. Call (888) 305-5422.

Talk to a real person today. Call (888) 305-5422. Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM. Testing by appointment, including evenings and weekends.

Not ready to call? Request a callback.